INSURANCE

PEACE OF MIND

PROTECTION

INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENCY
Family Dog

WHO

WE ARE

No one can predict the future; however, at Sutton Insurance, we want to help you prepare for whatever comes your way. The staff at Sutton Insurance is professional, friendly, and reliable. We want to help you make good choices to insure you have the coverage you need. We are an independent agency and represent a variety of insurance companies. This allows us to provide adequate coverage at a reasonable cost to you.

 

Sutton Insurance is a family-owned business in its third generation. We have served Southwest Wisconsin and Northeast Iowa since 1957. In addition, we now are licensed in Minnesota, Illinois and Arizona.

George Sutton, who passed away in 2018, started the business in 1957 while working with his father Amos Sutton in real estate. George’s son, Robert, joined the agency in 1977 and continued the family legacy until finally retiring in 2018. Kevin Mulrooney joined the agency in 1988 and writes all the health, life and long term care products, along with IRA’s and annuities and continues his journey with the agency as a specialist for over age 65 clients. Tarah Sutton Marx, Robert’s daughter, started with the agency in 2000, and is now the owner and writing and processing all commercial lines products as well as personal lines. In 2012, the agency purchased White Insurance after Paul White retired and hired Paul’s long time employee, agent Sally Whitish. Sally is a licensed agent and writes and services personal and commercial lines clients. Sally has 40 years of insurance experience and is a wonderful addition to our staff. Carlee Monroe, started with the agency in 2015, is licensed and writes and services personal lines clients. Carlee is a true asset to our organization.

 
White Feather

OUR

COVERAGE

Sutton Insurance can help you navigate the complex world of insurance plans because we are independent agents with a commitment to tailoring insurance coverage to our customers’ needs. Whether you need coverage for your home, business, or auto, we can help you find the coverage you need. We also write life insurance policies to protect your family against unfortunate, unforeseen events.

Products Offered:
  • Auto

  • Home

  • Snowmobile

  • ATV & Boat

  • Motorcycle & RV

  • Annuities

  • IRAs

  • Disability

  • Dental

  • Medicare Supplements

 
 

OUR 

AFFILIATIONS

Sutton Insurance, Inc. is a Trusted Choice® Agency. What does that mean? We have taken a Pledge of Performance to promise that we will hold ourselves to higher standards and put you, our client, first. Because you’re a person, not a policy.

Riding with Pumpkins

FUN

FACTS

1957

BUSINESS
ESTABLISHED

3rd

GENERATION
FAMILY OWNED

20+

CARRIERS
REPRESENTED

5

STATES LICENSED IN
 

GET IN

TOUCH

We can't wait to hear from you!

Are you currently a customer?

If yes, click here to complete a renewal review form.

Sutton Insurance, Inc.

106 W. Blackhawk Avenue

P.O. Box 208

Prairie du Chien, Wisconsin 53821

Phone: 608-326-8461

Fax: 608-326-8465

sutton@suttoninsuranceinc.com

Hours of Operation:

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

Tuesday: 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

Wednesday 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

Thursday: 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

Friday: 8:30 am - 4:00 pm

Saturday: Closed

Closed daily from Noon until 1:00pm

 

Serving clients in Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota, Illinois and Arizona since 1957.

Follow Us On Facebook:

  • White Facebook Icon

Insurance coverage cannot be bound or changed via submission trough this website, e-mail, text, voice mail or facsimile. No binder, insurance policy, change, addition, and/or deletion to insurance coverage goes into effect unless and until confirmed directly with a licensed agent. Note any proposal of insurance we may present to you will be based upon the values developed and exposures to loss disclosed to us on this online form/application and/or in communications with us. All coverages are subject to the terms, conditions and exclusions of the actual policy issued. Not all policies or coverages are available in every state.

©

2020

Sutton Insurance, Inc.  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy